Home/When a Roofing Supplier Offers a Substitute, Who Clears It?

When a Roofing Supplier Offers a Substitute, Who Clears It?

Imagine the supplier calls two days before a commercial reroof. One item on the purchase order is back-ordered, and the supplier offers a replacement that can ship this afternoon. The project manager needs an answer fast. The buyer needs to know which item to order. The superintendent needs an instruction the crew can follow.

Give the proposed substitution one record that can answer those three questions. Keep it tied to the exact material, job area and written decision so the purchase order and field instructions can be checked against the same version.

Start with the item the job already calls for

Open the project’s current material record and find the specified or previously approved item. Capture the manufacturer, product name and identifier, along with the submittal or specification reference and the area where it applies. Then record the proposed product at the same level of detail. Describe why the supplier raised it, when the original and proposed items can be delivered, and which work depends on the decision. Leave any unanswered field visible.

Ask for current documents for the exact product being proposed. For example, the GAF document library lists commercial data sheets, details, technical bulletins, and installation instructions. Start with the proposed product’s own manufacturer. Put the document revision or date beside each attachment so the next reviewer can tell which version was used.

Send the proposal to the reviewer named for this job

Check the project documents for the review path and timing. Route technical questions to the designated project reviewer, using any additional reviewers the project calls for. Give them the original and proposed item together, explain the reason for the change, and say when the decision is needed to keep the work moving. If you already know there may be a difference in details, cost, lead time, or warranty documentation, list it as a question or impact for review.

Newberry County’s public Gallman Place roof replacement addendum includes a bid-period substitution request with supporting product information and a separate design-team decision section. That form is specific to its project and phase. The useful idea for the job file is to record the request and its disposition separately, with the evidence attached.

Translate the decision into purchasing and field instructions

Keep the affected line pending until the project’s required review is complete. If delivery is getting close, assign the project manager a follow-up time and ask the supplier to confirm how long the proposed item will be available. A customer schedule update can explain what is pending and when you will check back without promising a material, price or install date.

When the decision arrives, save the written response and record its scope. If the reviewer accepted the item for one roof area with a condition, carry both details into the purchase instruction and the applicable work packet. Assign someone to verify that both copies reference the same decision. If the reviewer declines the proposal, record that result and confirm the next supply or schedule step with the project manager. Keep the original purchase line and decision history accessible.

Use one record from request through delivery

  • Request. Job and roof area, original item, exact proposed item, reason, and required decision date.
  • Evidence. Current product documents, known differences, open questions and the person responsible for resolving each one.
  • Disposition. Written response, approver, date, covered area, conditions and any remaining approval.
  • Release. Updated purchase line, current field instruction, and who acknowledged each one.
  • Receiving. Exact item received and any discrepancy sent back to the project manager for resolution before use.

In a fictional example, a reviewer accepts an alternate cover board for Area B and leaves Area A on the original selection. The buyer records the two areas on separate purchase lines and the superintendent checks the current work packet before materials are placed. If both items arrive on one packing slip with no roof areas listed, receiving asks the project manager to reconcile the order and package labels before the material goes to the crew. The team can trace the next decision without reconstructing a phone call.

Try this with your next supplier substitution. Ask the buyer to find the written decision from the purchase line, then ask the superintendent to find the same decision from the field packet. Fix the link or the work instruction if they land on different documents. For related handoffs, see which roofing documents to update when scope changes. To explore Centerpoint Connect with your own workflow in mind, request a live demo.

Related Posts

Scroll to Top